<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Publishing DTD v1.3 20210610//EN" "JATS-journalpublishing1-3.dtd">
<article article-type="research-article" dtd-version="1.3" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xml:lang="ru">
 <front>
  <journal-meta>
   <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">afjournal</journal-id>
   <journal-title-group>
    <journal-title xml:lang="ru">Анализ и прогноз. Журнал ИМЭМО РАН</journal-title>
    <trans-title-group xml:lang="en">
     <trans-title>Analysis &amp; Forecasting. Journal of IMEMO</trans-title>
    </trans-title-group>
   </journal-title-group>
   <issn pub-type="epub">2713-170X</issn>
   <publisher>
    <publisher-name xml:lang="ru">ИМЭМО РАН</publisher-name>
   </publisher>
  </journal-meta>
  <article-meta>
   <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.20542/afij-2019-2-33-47</article-id>
   <article-categories>
    <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
     <subject>Research Article</subject>
    </subj-group>
    <subj-group subj-group-type="section-heading" xml:lang="ru">
     <subject>Статьи</subject>
    </subj-group>
   </article-categories>
   <title-group>
    <article-title xml:lang="ru">Сравнительный анализ приоритетов Франции и ФРГ в развитии PESCO</article-title>
    <trans-title-group xml:lang="en">
     <trans-title>Comparative Analysis of French and German Priorities in the Elaboration of PESCO</trans-title>
    </trans-title-group>
   </title-group>
   <aff-alternatives id="aff-1">
    <aff xml:lang="ru">
     <institution>ТИМОФЕЕВ Павел Петрович, кандидат политических наук, старший научный сотрудник Сектора региональных проблем и конфликтов Отдела европейских политических исследований.
Национальный исследовательский институт мировой экономики и международных отношений им. Е.М. Примакова РАН, РФ, 117997 Москва, Профсоюзная, 23 ( p . timofeyev @ gmail . com ).

Статья выполнена в рамках проекта РФФИ № 18-011-00464 “Меняющаяся роль Германии в евроинтеграционных и трансатлантических процессах. Вызовы для России”.</institution>
    </aff>
   </aff-alternatives>
   <contrib-group>
    <contrib contrib-type="author" id="author-1" corresp="yes">
     <contrib-id contrib-id-type="orcid">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0512-7436</contrib-id>
     <name-alternatives>
      <name name-style="eastern" xml:lang="ru">
       <surname>Тимофеев</surname>
       <given-names>Павел Петрович</given-names>
      </name>
      <name name-style="western" xml:lang="en">
       <surname>Timofeev</surname>
       <given-names>Pavel</given-names>
      </name>
     </name-alternatives>
     <bio xml:lang="ru">
      <p>Образование:
МГУ им. М.В. Ломоносова (Исторический факультет)
2011 г. – кандидат политических наук. Тема диссертации: «Европейское направление внешней политики Франции после окончания “холодной войны”»

Сфера научных интересов:

внешняя и внутренняя политика современной Франции
российско-французские отношения
внешняя политика ЕС
международные отношения в Средиземноморье и на Ближнем Востоке

С 2017 г. – член Государственной аттестационной комиссии на Историческом факультете МГУ имени М.В. Ломоносова
С 2020 г. – эксперт РАН
С 2020 г. – представитель Отделения глобальных проблем и международных отношений в Совете молодых ученых РАН
Победитель конкурса лучших исследователей-международников МГИМО в номинации «Лучшая научная статья молодого ученого» за статью «Отношения России и Франции: актуальные проблемы и состояние (2012-2015)»
Иностранные языки: французский, английский

Профиль автора в Science Index
Профиль автора в Scopus</p>
     </bio>
     <bio xml:lang="en">
      <p>Education:
2007 – Graduated from Lomonosov Moscow State University (Department of History)
2010 – Completed post-graduate studies at IMEMO
2011 – PhD in Political Science at IMEMO. D. thesis: &quot;The European direction of French foreign policy after the end of the Cold War&quot;

Fields of scientific interests:

Foreign and domestic policy of modern France
Russian-French relations
EU foreign policy
International relations in the Mediterranean and the Middle East

Foreign languages: French, English
Professional and additional activities:
since 2017 – Member of the State Attestation Commission at the Faculty of History of Lomonosov Moscow State University
since 2020 – Expert of the Russian Academy of Sciences
since 2020 – representative of the Department of Global Affairs and International Relations at the RAS Council of Young Scientists

Winner of the MGIMO Best International Researchers Competition in the category &quot;Best Research Paper by a Young Researcher&quot; for the article &quot;Russia-France Relations: Current Problems and State (2012–2015)&quot;</p>
     </bio>
     <email>pavel.timofeyev@yandex.ru</email>
     <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-1"></xref>
    </contrib>
   </contrib-group>
   <pub-date pub-type="epub">
    <day>17</day>
    <month>07</month>
    <year>2019</year>
   </pub-date>
   <issue>2</issue>
   <fpage>33</fpage>
   <lpage>47</lpage>
   <permissions>
    <copyright-statement xml:lang="ru">© 2019 г. П. Тимофеев
Статья поступила в редакцию 17.07.2019.</copyright-statement>
    <copyright-statement xml:lang="en">© 2019 P. Timofeev
Received 17.07.2019.</copyright-statement>
    <copyright-year>2019</copyright-year>
    <copyright-holder xml:lang="ru">Тимофеев П.П.</copyright-holder>
    <copyright-holder xml:lang="en">Timofeev P.</copyright-holder>
   </permissions>
   <self-uri xlink:href="https://www.afjournal.ru/2019/2/world-politics/comparative-analysis-of-french-and-german-priorities-in-the-elaboration-of-pesco">https://www.afjournal.ru/2019/2/world-politics/comparative-analysis-of-french-and-german-priorities-in-the-elaboration-of-pesco</self-uri>
   <abstract>
    <p>В статье анализируются подходы Франции и Германии к созданию Постоянного структурированного сотрудничества ( PESCO ) в рамках европейского интеграционного объединения. Рассмотрена краткая история PESCO , показаны общие цели Парижа и Берлина в этом проекте, детально рассмотрены подходы Франции и Германии, их приоритеты в работе над конкретными направлениями, позиции в вопросе о сочетании PESCO и НАТО. Сделан вывод о том, что единение Франции и ФРГ в работе над PESCO выглядит многообещающе и может укрепить оборонную конвергенцию в Европейском союзе. В то же время показаны объективные ограничители, способные застопорить, а то и полностью сорвать данный проект.</p>
   </abstract>
   <trans-abstract xml:lang="en">
    <p>The article focuses on the French and German approaches towards Permanent structured cooperation (PESCO) – a new EU defense initiative launched in 2017. The author shows PESCO as well as European integration became a result of the compromises of European states, led by both France and Germany. Following brief history of PESCO, the author compares two approaches towards PESCO objectives, content, concrete practical projects and correlation between PESCO and NATO. The author highlights common points in the positions of Paris and Berlin: their goal – strengthening the military-political potential of the EU in the world; their willingness to work together on specific and prospective projects (including modernization of combat helicopters and the creation of flying eurodrones) and understanding of PESCO as not an alternative for NATO. In the same time the author shows the specifics and the differences of both approaches, based on geography, economy and pragmatism, law and military traditions, competition for EU leadership. Dominating German approach is “inclusive” and more cautious: it aims at the progressive development of European integration in the military area, which, through joint political and economic efforts of all EU member states, should lead to a common defense policy. French approach being more “ambitious” aims at shaping a group of states led by France, capable of conducting interventions - thus solving offensive tasks. Two different philosophies determine distinct views on concrete projects: France is more proactive than Germany and shows a greater interest in projects related to the direct conduct of hostilities. Berlin is seeking to focus on more “technical” cases. Finally, Paris and Berlin see the PESCO relationship with NATO in different ways: PESCO is seen in Germany as an addition to the Alliance, while France avoids comparing both structures, perhaps planning to give PESCO more ambitious scope in the future. The author concludes the French-German cooperation in the work on PESCO looks promising and can strengthen EU defense convergence. At the same time, the article shows objective limitations that could stop or completely disrupt this project.

About author:
Pavel P. TIMOFEEV, Cand. Sci. (Polit.), Senior Researcher, Sector of Regional Issues and Conflicts, Department of European Political Studies.</p>
   </trans-abstract>
   <kwd-group xml:lang="ru">
    <kwd>Франция</kwd>
    <kwd>Германия</kwd>
    <kwd>PESCO</kwd>
    <kwd>Европейский союз</kwd>
    <kwd>НАТО</kwd>
    <kwd>безопасность</kwd>
    <kwd>оборона</kwd>
    <kwd>европейская интеграция</kwd>
   </kwd-group>
   <kwd-group xml:lang="en">
    <kwd>France</kwd>
    <kwd>Germany</kwd>
    <kwd>PESCO</kwd>
    <kwd>European Union</kwd>
    <kwd>NATO</kwd>
    <kwd>security</kwd>
    <kwd>defense</kwd>
    <kwd>European integration</kwd>
   </kwd-group>
   <custom-meta-group>
    <custom-meta>
     <meta-name>UDK</meta-name>
     <meta-value>(430)+(44): 327(4)+341.238+430+441</meta-value>
    </custom-meta>
   </custom-meta-group>
  </article-meta>
 </front>
 <back>
  <ref-list>
   <title>References</title>
   <ref id="cit1">
    <label>1</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Notification on Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) to the Council and to the High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy . Council of the European Union. 17.11.2013. Available at: http://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/31511/171113-pesco-notification.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit2">
    <label>2</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Rapport d’information № 719 déposé par la Commission des affaires européennes sur l'Europe de la défense et son articulation avec l'OTAN et présenté par MM. Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade et Joaquim Pueyo, députés . Assemblée Nationale. 22.02.2018. Available at: http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/15/europe/rap-info/i0719.asp (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit3">
    <label>3</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Bonde J.-P. ed. The Lisbon Treaty. The Readable version. Grafisk, Foundation for EU democracy, 2009. 384 p. Available at: en.euabc.com/upload/books/lisbon-treaty-3edition.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit4">
    <label>4</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. La défense devient priorité n°1, la parole se libère, les projets sortent. Merci David! Bruxelles2 , 28.06.2016. Available at: https://www.bruxelles2.eu/2016/06/28/la-defense-devient-priorite-n1-la-parole-se-libere-les-projets-sortent-merci-david (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit5">
    <label>5</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">La Coopération Structurée Permanente: Perspectives nationales et état d'avancement. Parlement européen . 17.07.2017. Available at: https://www.grip.org/fr/node/2384 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit6">
    <label>6</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Shared Vision, Common Action: A Stronger Europe. A Global Strategy for the European Union’s Foreign And Security Policy. European Union External Action. June 2016. Available at: http://eeas.europa.eu/archives/docs/top_stories/pdf/eugs_review_web.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit7">
    <label>7</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. La lente mise en place de la Coopération structurée permanente (PESCO) (V3). Bruxelles2 , 06.03.2018. Available at: https://club.bruxelles2.eu/2018/03/lunion-europeenne-de-defense-alias-la-cooperation-structuree-permanente/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit8">
    <label>8</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">European Council conclusions on security and defence . Council of the European Union. 22.06.2017. Available at: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2017/06/22/euco-security-defence/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit9">
    <label>9</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. La PESCO (Coopération structurée permanente) au podium (V2). Bruxelles2 , 14.12.2017. Available at: https://www.bruxelles2.eu/2017/12/14/la-cooperation-structuree-permanente-officiellement-lancee/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit10">
    <label>10</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) updated list of PESCO projects – Overview. Council of the European Union. 19.11.2018. Available at: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/37028/table-pesco-projects.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit11">
    <label>11</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Pertusot V. European Defence: The Tipping Point. Challenges ahead for Global Europe Discussion Papers for Session 3 of the BTTD 2014 jointly organised by the French Institute for International Relations (Ifri), Friends of Europe and Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP) . Institut français des relations internationales, 2014, pp. 3-6. Available at: https://www.ifri.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/bttd2014workingpapersession3final.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit12">
    <label>12</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">White Paper on German Security Policy and the Future of the Bundeswehr . 2016. Available at: https://fmp.msu.ru/anthology/countries/item/1448-white-paper-2016-on-german-security-policy-and-the-future-of-the-bundeswehr (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit13">
    <label>13</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Revue stratégique de défense et de sécurité nationale . Octobre 2017. Available at: https://www.defense.gouv.fr/dgris/presentation/evenements-archives/revue-strategique-de-defense-et-de-securite-nationale-2017 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit14">
    <label>14</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Barluet A. La feuille de route franco-allemande pour relancer l'Europe de la défense. Le Figaro , 11.09.2016. Available at: http://premium.lefigaro.fr/international/2016/09/11/01003-20160911ARTFIG00140-la-feuille-de-route-franco-allemande-pour-relancer-l-europe-de-la-defense.php (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit15">
    <label>15</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Clemenceau F. L'Allemagne et la France relancent la défense européenne. Le Journal du Dimanche , 11.09.2016. Available at: https://www.lejdd.fr/International/Allemagne-et-France-relancent-la-defense-europeenne-808408 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit16">
    <label>16</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">19ème Conseil des ministres franco-allemand – Paris . 13.07.2017. Available at: https://www.france-allemagne.fr/19eme-Conseil-des-ministres-franco-allemand-Paris-le-13-juillet-2017.html (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit17">
    <label>17</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">La coopération structurée permanente . 13.11.2017. Available at: https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-fr/recherche/la-coop%C3%A9ration-structur%C3%A9e-permanente-440038 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit18">
    <label>18</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Басов Ф., Васильев В., Кокеев А., Хорольская М. Немецкое представление о безопасности. Международная жизнь , 2018, №10, сс.37-54. [Basov F., Vasil'ev V., Kokeev A., Khorol'skaya M. Nemetskoe predstavlenie o bezopasnosti [German vision of security]. International Affairs , 2018, no.10, pp.37-54]. Available at: https://interaffairs.ru/jauthor/material/2089 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit19">
    <label>19</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Stockmans P. Sven Biscop: “Si l'armée européenne est reportée à nouveau, nous ne révélons que notre faiblesse”. Mondiaal nieuws , 12.04.2017. Available at: https://www.mo.be/fr/interview/sven-biscop-si-l-ue-ne-forme-pas-maintenant-son-arm-e-elle-s-exposera-dans-toute-sa-vuln (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit20">
    <label>20</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Thomann P-E. L’armée européenne: une utopie commode. Eurocontinent , 19.11.2018. Available at: http://www.eurocontinent.eu/2018/11/larmee-europeenne-une-utopie-commode/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit21">
    <label>21</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Germany's Constitution of 1949 with Amendments through 2012 . Available at: https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/German_Federal_Republic_2012.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit22">
    <label>22</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Kunz B. L'Allemagne mise au défi d'une d é fense européenne . IFRI . 13.11.2017. Available at: https://www.ifri.org/fr/espace-media/lifri-medias/lallemagne-mise-defi-dune-defense-europeenne (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit23">
    <label>23</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Kunz B. Macron, l’Allemagne et la laborieuse relance de l’Europe de la défense. Les Echos , 19.04.2018. Available at: https://www.lesechos.fr/idees-debats/cercle/macron-lallemagne-et-la-laborieuse-relance-de-leurope-de-la-defense-131915 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit24">
    <label>24</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. Un noyau dur devenu chamallow. Une coopération structurée permanente: pour quoi faire? Bruxelles2 , 12.05.2017. Available at: https://www.bruxelles2.eu/2017/05/12/un-noyau-dur-devenu-chamallow-une-cooperation-structuree-permanente-pour-quoi-faire/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit25">
    <label>25</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Fabry E., Koenig N., Pellerin-Carlin T. Renforcer l’Europe de la défense grâce à la PESCO: qui se met à table? Et quell est le menu? Institut Delors , 20.10.2017. Available at: http://www.institutdelors.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/renforcerladfenseeuropenne-tribune-fabrykoenigpellerincarlin-oct17.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit26">
    <label>26</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Constitution française du 4 octobre 1958. Available at: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/Droit-francais/Constitution/Constitution-du-4-octobre-1958 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit27">
    <label>27</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Thomann P-E. PESCO: vers l’autonomie stratégique ou la grande illusion? Brussels Star , 23.11.2017. Available at: https://brussels-star.com/2017/11/23/pesco-vers-lautonomie-strategique-ou-la-grande-illusion/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit28">
    <label>28</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. La PESCO, le nouveau projet européen de défense va voir le jour (V2). Bruxelles2 , 10.11.2017. Available at: https://www.bruxelles2.eu/2017/11/10/la-pesco-le-nouveau-projet-europeen-de-defense-va-voir-le-jour/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit29">
    <label>29</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Initiative pour l'Europe – Discours d'Emmanuel Macron pour une Europe souveraine, unie, démocratique. Présidence de la République Française . 26.09.2017. Available at: https://www.elysee.fr/emmanuel-macron/2017/09/26/initiative-pour-l-europe-discours-d-emmanuel-macron-pour-une-europe-souveraine-unie-democratique (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit30">
    <label>30</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Londres soutient la force d'intervention européenne pour exister après le Brexit. L'Orient le jour , 05.05.2018. Available at: https://www.lorientlejour.com/article/1113869/londres-soutient-la-force-dintervention-europeenne-pour-exister-apres-le-brexit.html (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit31">
    <label>31</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Gros-Verheyde N. № 62. L’initiative européenne d’intervention (V3). Bruxelles2 , 18.06.2018. Available at: https://club.bruxelles2.eu/2018/06/linitiative-europeenne-dintervention/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit32">
    <label>32</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Mölling, C., Major, C. Die Europäische Interventionsinitiative EI2. DGAPkompakt, 2018, № 10, Juni. Available at: https://dgap.org/system/files/article_pdfs/2018-10-dgapkompakt_0.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit33">
    <label>33</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Letter of intent concerning the development of the European Intervention Initiative (EI2) . 25.06.2018. Available at: https://club.bruxelles2.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/let-intention-initiativeeuropintervention@fr180625.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit34">
    <label>34</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Défense européenne: première réunion ministérielle au format IEI . Communiqué du ministère des Armées . 08.11.2018. Available at: https://ue.delegfrance.org/defense-europeenne-premiere (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit35">
    <label>35</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">L'Initiative européenne d'intervention. Ministère des Armées . 26.02.2019. Available at: https://www.defense.gouv.fr/dgris/action-internationale/l-iei/l-initiative-europeenne-d-intervention (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit36">
    <label>36</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Bault O. Vingt-cinq pays de l’UE adhèrent à la “coopération structurée permanente” (CSP, ou PESCO) dans le domaine de la défense, mais avec des visions divergentes. Reinformation.tv , 12.12.2017. Available at: https://reinformation.tv/cooperation-structuree-permanente-csp-pesco-ue-defense-bault-78177-2/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit37">
    <label>37</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Puhl D. Progrès et limites de la politique de défense commune. Boulevard extérieur , 25.04.2019. Available at: https://www.boulevard-exterieur.com/Progres-et-limites-de-la-politique-de-defense-commune.html (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit38">
    <label>38</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Tilenni G. PESCO: une analyse préliminaire. EuroDéfense-France , 12.02.2018. Available at: https://eurodefense.fr/2018/02/23/pesco-une-analyse-preliminaire/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit39">
    <label>39</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Lenoir M. PESCO: l’Europe de la Défense chère à Macron déjà marquée par sa faiblesse et son incohérence. Reinformation.tv , 14.11.2017. Available at: http://reinformation.tv/pesco-europe-defense-macron-faiblesse-incoherence-77106-2/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit40">
    <label>40</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Koller F. Les Européens s’affirment face aux Etats-Unis. Le Temps , 16.02.2018. Available at: https://www.letemps.ch/monde/europeens-saffirment-face-aux-etatsunis (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit41">
    <label>41</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Vincent R. Europe de la défense: les Etats-Unis, l’OTAN et les pays baltes restent perplexes. Forces Operations Blog , 19.02.2018. Available at: http://forcesoperations.com/europe-de-la-defense-les-etats-unis-lotan-et-les-pays-baltes-restent-perplexes/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit42">
    <label>42</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Lagneau L. Pour l’Union européenne, la défense commune relève de l’Otan. Zone militaire , 15.02.2018. Available at: http://www.opex360.com/2018/02/15/lunion-europeenne-defense-commune-releve-de-lotan/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit43">
    <label>43</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Déclaration de M. Jean-Yves Le Drian à son arrivée au conseil Affaires étrangères (Bruxelles, 13 novembre 2017) . Available at: https://ue.delegfrance.org/la-cooperation-structuree (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit44">
    <label>44</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">La France en pointe dans la construction de l’Europe de la défense . Ministère des Armées . 21.12.2018. Available at: https://www.defense.gouv.fr/dga/actualite/la-france-en-pointe-dans-la-construction-de-l-europe-de-la-defense (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit45">
    <label>45</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">L'OTAN . Ministère des Armées . 15.07.2019. Available at: https://www.defense.gouv.fr/dgris/action-internationale/l-otan/l-otan (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit46">
    <label>46</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Lagneau L. Le président Macron veut que l’Otan soit “unie, solidaire, crédible et efficace”. Zone militaire , 15.05.2018. Available at: http://www.opex360.com/2018/05/15/president-macron-veut-lotan-soit-unie-solidaire-credible-efficace/ (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit47">
    <label>47</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Discours du Président de la République à l'ouverture de la conférence des Ambassadeurs . La Présidence de la République . 29.08.2017. Available at: https://www.elysee.fr/emmanuel-macron/2017/08/29/discours-du-president-de-la-republique-a-l-ouverture-de-la-conference-des-ambassadeurs (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit48">
    <label>48</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Discours du Président de la République à la conférence des Ambassadeurs . La Présidence de la République . 27.08.2018. Available at: https://www.elysee.fr/emmanuel-macron/2018/08/27/discours-du-president-de-la-republique-a-la-conference-des-ambassadeurs (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit49">
    <label>49</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Manthey F. PESCO: Ein Meilenstein auf dem WegzurVerteidigungsunion. Bundesministerium der Verteidigung , 13.11.2017. Available at: https://www.bmvg.de/de/aktuelles/pesco-ein-meilenstein-auf-dem-weg-zur-verteidigungsunion-19806 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit50">
    <label>50</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Speech by Federal Minister of Defence Dr Ursula von der Leyen on the occasion of the opening of the 54th Munich Security Conference in Munich on 16 February 2018 . Available at: https://www.bmvg.de/resource/blob/22180/a4b7d92394e5ff6b7689c79cc71fa9d9/20180216-download-eroeffnungsrede-englisch-data.pdf (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit51">
    <label>51</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Schultz T. Can PESCO provide a new European identity? Deutsche Welle , 13.11.2017. Available at: https://www.dw.com/en/can-pesco-provide-a-new-european-identity/a-41362789 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit52">
    <label>52</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Bennhold K., Erlanger S. Merkel Joins Macron in Calling for a European Army ‘One Day’. New York Times , 13.11.2018. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/13/world/europe/merkel-macron-european-army.html (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit53">
    <label>53</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Erlanger S. U.S. Revives Concerns About European Defense Plans, Rattling NATO Allies. New York Times , 18.02.2018. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/18/world/europe/nato-europe-us-.html (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit54">
    <label>54</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Tsikalas M. Interview with German Defence Minister Ursula von der Leyen. KNEWS Kathimerini , 18.03.2019. Available at: https://knews.kathimerini.com.cy/en/news/interview-with-german-defence-minister-ursula-von-der-leyen (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit55">
    <label>55</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Leymarie Ph. Les noces d’or du couple franco-allemand. Le Monde diplomatique , 22.01.2019. Available at: https://blog.mondediplo.net/les-noces-d-or-du-couple-franco-allemand (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
   <ref id="cit56">
    <label>56</label>
    <mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Major C., Mölling C. Franco-German Differences Over Defense Make Europe Vulnerable. Carnegie Europe , 29.03.2018. Available at: https://carnegieehttps://www.oprf.ru/ru/press/news/2019/newsitem/51569urope.eu/strategiceurope/75937 (accessed 12.07.2019).</mixed-citation>
   </ref>
  </ref-list>
  <fn-group>
   <fn fn-type="conflict">
    <p>The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.</p>
   </fn>
  </fn-group>
 </back>
</article>
